BMW M5 review – the most economical M5 ever

Verdict – is the BMW M5 a good car?

The BMW M5 is an impressive super saloon for the times we live in. It’s incredibly fast, surprisingly economical if you’re careful, able to run on electricity, and very comfortable. The problem is, it’s lacking some soul because of a slightly numbed driving experience and its heavy weight, but it serves as a remarkable basis on which to base more focused future iterations.

BMW M5 models, specs and alternatives

BMW’s M cars are the legendary performance variants of the brand’s regular lineup of cars – the first of its pedestrian lineup to get the treatment was the 5 Series-based BMW M5 (the first M car ever was the standalone BMW M1 supercar) and it’s become an iconic model since then. That means this latest version has not only big boots to fill, but also bigger obstacles to overcome, such as more stringent emissions regulations.

For that reason, the biggest thing that separates the new M5 from the car it replaces is that it’s a plug-in hybrid, using a combination of petrol and electric power to deliver the type of performance people will expect, while keeping emissions down and fuel economy frugal. As a result, the latest BMW M5 is a controversial car, because it’s not solely petrol-powered as it has been in the past, so there’s also the challenge of appeasing the purist naysayers.

Top 10 fastest saloon cars 2024

The latest BMW M5 is eye-wateringly expensive, starting from over £110,000 in saloon form, while the Touring estate costs £2,000 more. It’s very well equipped, at least, and there aren’t any trim levels as such, but buyers can specify lots of optional extras such as an M Driver’s Package which bumps the top speed up from 155mph to 189mph.

There’s no hardcore Competition Pack like the one offered on the M3, but it’s still early days and no doubt more performance-focused versions of the M5 will arrive later down the line. 

15

This time around, the BMW M5 is no longer a petrol-only model but instead powered by a combination of petrol and electric power by way of a plug-in hybrid system. That means it’s got the lowest on-paper CO2 emissions and best fuel economy of any BMW M5 that’s come before it, plus the ability to drive for up to 42 miles on electricity alone. Potentially that makes the latest M5 one of the easiest in its history to live with day to day, as you can manage short trips to the shops or around town without using a drop of fuel.

Of course, this all depends on your driving and lifestyle, because you’ll need to keep the battery constantly topped up if you’re to come anywhere near those quoted figures. Charging up via a home wallbox charger at speeds of 7.4kW will take you around 3 hours and 15 minutes, while BMW says this will soon be upgraded to 11kW which will bring that time down to just two hours, so long as you have a compatible charger.
 

How efficient is the BMW M5 in the real world?

While the BMW M5’s lofty fuel-economy figures are impressive, bear in mind that these are only attainable by keeping it charged and by driving in a less spirited manner. During testing we achieved average fuel consumption of between 33 and 35mpg over two days – that’s still impressive for a car with this much power on offer, and from such a large engine.

How much will the BMW M5 cost in tax?

Because of its status as a low-emissions vehicle thanks to that plug-in hybrid powertrain, the BMW M5 should be less expensive than ever to run as a company car because BiK (Benefit-in-Kind) tax rates should be low.

What will the BMW M5 cost to insure?

Official insurance group ratings for the latest M5 are yet to be confirmed, but we’d expect it to sit in the highest group 50 out of 50, making it expensive to insure.

15

This generation of BMW M5 is the most complex there’s ever been. It swaps pure petrol power for a plug-in hybrid setup, which could irk some purists, but it does mean it’s the most powerful BMW M5 ever with 717bhp.

In many ways you could argue that the latest M5 doesn’t really go against the original recipe – it’s a car that’s designed to be easy to live with and as practical and classy as you can expect a saloon to be, but with all the performance and driver focus sitting dormant, ready to transform into something that would give a supercar a run for its money. The criteria for what makes a super saloon usable day to day has changed over time, so the fact you can glide along sedately in Electric mode at speeds of up to 87mph is very in-keeping with what modern car buyers are looking for.

Put the M5 into Hybrid mode and its computer juggles between the electric motor and monstrous V8 engine to decide on how best to deliver power efficiently. The breadth of customisation is endless, and you’re able to fine-tune the settings for the engine, gearbox, chassis, steering and brakes via the M driver menu.

15

Dynamic and Dynamic Plus are the sportiest driving modes, and the only two in which the M5’s full 717bhp potential is available. Here, the sense of speed is very apparent from behind the wheel when you put your foot down – that’s quite impressive, especially because the BMW M5 is also very heavy given all the PHEV gubbins it has to haul around.

However, while it’s certainly fast, we’re not the biggest fans of how it sounds getting up to full pelt. The V8 engine note can be enhanced via system settings, but no amount of tweaks make it as sonorous as its rawer forebears. There’s a lack of depth to the engine which makes it feel a little artificial and flat, which is a little disappointing.

As we’ve already established, the BMW M5 is well capable of delivering its performance, despite its weight, and its brakes are immensely powerful too. We were impressed with how well the M5 rides as well, even when it’s put into Dynamic mode. Grip is fantastic thanks to the huge 20 and 21-inch Michelin Plot Sport 5S tyres. Four-wheel steering, four-wheel drive and a well-judged suspension setup mean it’s well-planted no matter what you throw at it.

15

However, despite all these undeniably impressive qualities, the BMW M5 offers very little in the way of feedback through the steering or from the driver’s seat. While the steering response is excellent and grip is infallible, it just feels rather numb. It’s possible that’s been done on purpose, though, with more engaging versions of the model set to arrive in future to cater for more hardcore buyers.

This base version of the M5 is something to build on, then, and seems to have been designed to appeal as more of an all-rounder – it’s refined on the motorway and capable on A-roads, but it’s less enjoyable and engaging on a twisty B-road; a place where it can feel a bit numb and physically too big.

Plug-in hybrid models

The BMW M5’s plug-in hybrid setup boasts an eye-watering 717bhp and comprises a 4.4-litre twin-turbocharged V8 engine paired with an electric motor. That means it does the 0-62mph sprint in just 3.5 seconds, when fitted with launch control. Specify the M Driver’s Pack and the 155mph top speed is increased to 189mph.

Electric models 

While it’s not a full-blown M car, the most hardcore version of the all-electric BMW i5 gets some of the M treatment in M60 xDrive form, which boasts two electric motors supplying it with 593bhp.

15

BMW has been on a roll with its interior designs for years now, and the BMW M5 is no different. The M5’s cabin feels well built and beautifully finished just like that of the standard 5 Series, and it’s incredibly hi-tech, with its curved single panel housing the driver’s display and infotainment.

We like how easy all of the car’s instruments are to read, and the steering wheel gets two M  buttons that can be configured to your preferred Dynamic drive settings. Changing between drive modes also changes the feel of the cabin, with the ambient lighting defaulting to more calming colours in Comfort, and aggressive red tones when in Dynamic. Track mode tones every visual distraction down and the instrument display gets more focused, with just revs, tyre temperature, fluid temperature and other vital info shown.

Is the BMW M5 infotainment and sat-nav system easy to use?

The M5’s 14.9-inch infotainment screen looks incredibly crisp and slick and it’s easy to use for the most part. Just like in the standard 5 Series, it’s pretty easy to navigate the menus and there’s a Quick Select function that makes it even easier to jump to your favourite features without having to wade through too many submenus. We do wish there was quicker access to the ‘M-specific control panel’ where you can choose between the Normal, Dynamic and Track display settings, as well as yet more menus. It can be distracting to access these on the move as a result.

15

We like the 12.3-inch display that sits ahead of the driver – this shows all the main vehicle information concisely and vibrantly, and there’s a head-up display as standard, so you can keep your eyes on the road.

The Bowers & Wilkins sound system is made up of 18 speakers and a 655-watt amplifier with surround sound. It’s one of the best sound systems of any car we’ve driven and you can even swap the sound of music for the enhanced sound of the twin-turbo V8, should you wish to.

15

Though usually plug-in hybrid systems rob space from the interior and boots of the cars they power, the M5 offers lots of space inside. This current generation of M5 has very large dimensions, which means it’s got plenty of road presence, which is helped by its sportier styling and bodykit.

There’s abundant space for occupants, so as a result it’s just as comfortable to ride in for long journeys as any other BMW. It may just be the most practical and comfortable M car there’s ever been.

Does the BMW M5 have a big boot?

The BMW M5 boasts a surprisingly sizable 466-litre boot. It’s a good shape, too, so you should be able to get four good-sized suitcases in there with no problem. Every M5 gets a powered tailgate, which makes getting items in and out much easier if you’ve got your hands full. 

The BMW M5 also comes as an estate Touring version, should you want even more boot space. There’s obviously a wider opening to the hatchback tailgate, while the boot capacity is 500 litres, increasing to 1,630 litres with the rear seats down.

15

While the BMW M5 is a niche performance-focused model that won’t sell in high enough numbers to feature on our Driver Power customer satisfaction survey, BMW as a brand has been on the up in recent years, with the company placing in 14th position in the most recent 2024 brand survey. Customers love their cars’ engines, ride and handling, and infotainment tech, but value for money and running costs are ranked poorly. With the M5’s plug-in hybrid system keeping running costs down that shouldn’t be so much of an issue, but with it costing so much to buy in the first place, we doubt running costs will be high on buyers’ priority lists.

How safe is the BMW M5?

The BMW 5 Series was tested by Euro NCAP in 2023, and its five-star rating will also be applicable to the M5. Adult occupant protection was rated at 89%, child occupant protection at 85% and vulnerable road user protection at 86%. For its comprehensive suite of safety assistance features, the 5 Series achieved 78%.

Should you buy a BMW M5?

15

We think the BMW M5 is a fantastic option for those after a staggeringly-fast super saloon that also doubles as an economical everyday car, one that can even run on electricity for some of the time thanks to its plug-in hybrid system. What’s even more impressive is how comfortable it is, too, despite the potential that lays dormant in the background.

The thing is, while the M5 is undoubtedly quick, it doesn’t offer the most visceral experience, and there’s very little driving feel from behind the wheel, which means it’s rather numb. The V8 engine isn’t quite as sonorous as we’d like, and it’s a heavy car that – as impressively capable as it is – isn’t able to fully disguise its weight on the move. The M5 is brilliant and technically impressive in its own right, but perhaps it’s better to view it as a competent platform to build on for more focused versions on the horizon, that could appeal more to driving enthusiasts.

What is the Carbuyer pick of the BMW M5 range?

We think it’s worth going for the M5 Touring for the minimal £2,000 premium over the saloon because it adds that extra dose of practicality, while still boasting those impressive on-paper performance figures.

BMW M5 alternatives

Alternatives to the M5 include the Mercedes-AMG E 53, Porsche Panamera GTS and Audi RS6, though the latter is soon set to be replaced with a model of a different name following Audi’s revised naming structure. There are also electric rivals to consider, too, though the driving experience is less comparable.

• Mercedes-AMG E 53
• Porsche Panamera GTS
• Audi RS6 Avant
• Lotus Emeya
• Lucid Air

How we tested the BMW M5

We tested a left-hand drive version of the BMW M5 in October 2024 in Munich, Germany.